The thing that kills me is how many people think evolution should be taught just because people need to be exposed to different opinions. No, it should be taught because it is true. Graabbaelaelkeellele!!!
The upside to all of this? One of the few very-pro evolution contestants was the winner, with this response:
I was taught evolution in high school. I do believe in it. I’m a huge science geek. [...] I like to believe in the big bang theory and, you know, the evolution of humans throughout time.
Maybe there's some hope after all. Though I don't blame these women in particular. The US is woefully uneducated when it comes to evolution - they're just a product of our culture and terrible science standards.
EDIT: Miss Vermont wins at everything (13:00 in):
"I think evolution should be taught in schools because not everybody necessarily has the same religious background, and it's important to have scientific facts about the world. And we do know that evolution exists, even on a small scale like with people, and with bacteria that are becoming resistant to drugs and what not. So, might as well learn about it."